Sep 30, 2026

Deputy DA Dave Watson determined there was insufficient evidence to prove the charges beyond a reasonable doubt








I had already added the dismissal update with the court order on 9/24/26 to this previous post on James Whitchurch.

https://johnchiv.blogspot.com/2026/04/dui-suspect-james-whitchurch-is-no.html?m=1

Humboldt County DA Stacey Eads sent me this email to my inquiry about the dismissal in former EPD officer James Whitchurch case."The assigned DDA determined there was insufficient evidence to prove the charges beyond a reasonable doubt. The analysis took into consideration evidence available at the time of filing as well as additional information he received from a defense expert following the filing of charges."

I sent my inquiry today at 1:52 today, got a response at 2:12. Maybe DA Stacey Eads responded to me because I don't email her every other day and she knows, like most people, where readers go for Humboldt court coverage.

I covered the arrest and Whitchurch's case for months and regularly unlike the random court coverage by other local media.

DA Eads could have released a statement to all media but unlike the rest of the media I understand why that is not possible because I know what those who work in the local courts go through and their work conditions.

The public is correct to question Whitchurch's dismissal just as I did the DUI case dismissed for Humboldt Superior Court clerk Annisha Harris which only I covered.

The post also includes response from EPD Chief Brian Stephens.

EPD letter (10/1/26):

The Eureka Police Department is aware of the recent dismissal of charges against former Eureka Police Officer James Whitchurch. In response, Chief Stephens has prepared the following letter to the community addressing the Community’s concerns and the Department’s involvement in this matter.

“This incident involved an off-duty EPD officer and required accountability on more than one level. CHP independently investigated the alleged DUI and made the arrest. The Humboldt County District Attorney’s Office made the decision to file the criminal charge and ultimately dismissed it. Separately, EPD placed Mr. Whitchurch on administrative leave, conducted an internal inquiry into potential policy violations, and ended his employment. That inquiry was also reviewed by the City’s independent police auditor and reported to the Community Oversight on Police Practices Board.”

A longer response from EPD Chief Brian Stephens:

Good morning, Everyone

On September 30, 2026, I became aware that the criminal case against former Eureka Police Department (EPD) Officer James Whitchurch, stemming from his arrest for driving under the influence (DUI) on December 24, 2025, had been dismissed by the Humboldt County District Attorney’s Office. Like many of you, I learned of the dismissal through a local media report.

The news has understandably generated questions and concerns within our community. It has also led to confusion, misinformation, and allegations regarding the circumstances of the incident, the subsequent investigation, and the actions taken by the Eureka Police Department.

I want to take this opportunity to provide our community with the facts surrounding the initial call for service, the criminal investigation, and EPD’s internal administrative process.

Call for Service

On December 24, 2025, at approximately 8:21 p.m., EPD Dispatch received a 911 call regarding a family disturbance involving Mr. Whitchurch. The caller advised dispatch that Mr. Whitchurch had been consuming alcohol. During the call, the caller reported that Mr. Whitchurch was leaving in a vehicle with his wife and children and expressed concern that he was “driving drunk.” The caller provided an address in an adjacent jurisdiction where they believed Mr. Whitchurch and his family were headed.

EPD officers were dispatched to both the original location and the address in the adjacent jurisdiction. Upon arriving at the latter location, officers contacted Mr. Whitchurch and his family. The first-arriving officers observed an odor of an alcoholic beverage coming from Mr. Whitchurch, along with other signs of possible intoxication.

The officers contacted their Patrol Sergeant, who then notified an EPD Commander. Based on the circumstances, the Commander contacted me, and we determined that the California Highway Patrol (CHP) should be asked to take over the DUI investigation. CHP agreed to handle the investigation.

The Commander responded to the scene and met with the on-duty Sergeant and Mr. Whitchurch. The Commander informed Mr. Whitchurch that CHP would be conducting the investigation into the alleged DUI.

Upon CHP’s arrival, the investigation was turned over to their agency, and EPD’s investigative involvement ended. The on-duty Sergeant and Commander remained on scene near their respective vehicles until CHP completed its investigation.

Following its investigation, CHP determined that probable cause existed to believe Mr. Whitchurch had operated a motor vehicle while under the influence of alcohol and placed him under arrest.

The Commander contacted me and provided an update. I directed the Commander to notify Mr. Whitchurch that he was being placed on administrative leave, effective immediately.

The EPD officers who originally responded to the call for service documented their involvement in the incident in police reports as is the Department’s practice after responding to calls for service.

This concluded EPD’s involvement in the criminal DUI investigation.

To be clear, EPD did not investigate its own officer for the alleged DUI. We requested that CHP conduct the investigation on the evening of December 24, 2025, and CHP assumed full responsibility for investigating the allegations and making the associated investigative determinations. EPD personnel did not direct or control CHP’s investigation.

Criminal Investigation and Subsequent Dismissal

CHP subsequently completed its investigative reports and documentation and forwarded the case to the Humboldt County District Attorney’s Office for review.

The District Attorney’s Office filed a DUI charge against Mr. Whitchurch. On September 30, 2026, it was reported that the charge had been dismissed. It is important to understand that criminal charging decisions are made by prosecutors, not police departments. Police agencies investigate incidents and provide information to prosecutors, who independently decide whether to file, pursue, or dismiss criminal charges.

Beyond providing CHP with documentation of our officers’ initial observations and actions, EPD had no role in the District Attorney’s charging decision or the subsequent decision to dismiss the case.

EPD also had no contact with the District Attorney’s Office or the prosecuting Deputy District Attorney regarding the case after the charge was filed. The decision to dismiss the criminal charge was made by the District Attorney’s Office, not EPD.

EPD’s Internal Administrative Process

Separate from the criminal investigation, EPD initiated its own internal administrative process. Criminal cases and internal administrative reviews serve different purposes. A criminal case determines whether a person committed a crime under state law. An administrative review examines whether an employee complied with department policies and professional standards.

Immediately following Mr. Whitchurch’s arrest, I placed him on administrative leave. At the time of the events, Mr. Whitchurch was still in his probationary period as a newly hired officer. A “probationary period” is an evaluation period before an officer attains permanent status. On January 15, 2026, Mr. Whitchurch was released from his probationary period as a patrol officer, ending his employment with the Eureka Police Department.

An EPD Commander subsequently completed a Preliminary Inquiry into the arrest and the circumstances surrounding the incident. This review included reports and evidence provided by CHP, EPD reports, and body-worn camera footage from both agencies. The inquiry identified and sustained allegations of policy violations.

EPD submits formal complaints and Internal Affairs investigations to OIR Group, the independent police auditor retained by the City of Eureka, for review and comment. The Preliminary Inquiry was forwarded to OIR Group for independent review. Following its review, OIR Group determined that the inquiry was accurate, fair, and thorough, and concurred with its findings. In their report, OIR Group noted:

“The EPD officers who initially responded to the call for service were extremely professional and remained unbiased, despite their familiarity with the officer. Their initial on-scene investigations, and subsequent reports, were thorough and complete. While the ultimate decision to request outside agency involvement was appropriate, we remain confident that EPD handled the matter with professionalism, neutrality, and rigor”.

The independent auditor subsequently reported the findings of the inquiry to the Community Oversight on Police Practices Board during its July 28, 2026, quarterly public meeting.

Additionally, the Department reported the information to the Commission on Peace Officer Standards and Training (POST) for review as part of the state’s peace officer decertification system. Pursuant to California’s Senate Bill 2 framework, law enforcement agencies are required to report certain categories of serious misconduct to POST. The POST certification-review process operates entirely independently from the Department’s disciplinary process and the District Attorney’s criminal decisions.

This incident involved an off-duty EPD officer and required accountability on more than one level. CHP independently investigated the alleged DUI and made the arrest. The Humboldt County District Attorney’s Office made the decision to file the criminal charge and ultimately dismissed it. Separately, EPD placed Mr. Whitchurch on administrative leave, conducted an internal inquiry into potential policy violations, and ended his employment. That inquiry was also reviewed by the City’s independent police auditor and reported to the Community Oversight on Police Practices Board.

The dismissal of a criminal charge is a legal outcome, but it does not remove our responsibility to examine the conduct of our employees or to hold ourselves accountable to the standards expected of this department. We take allegations of misconduct seriously, regardless of whether they involve an on-duty or off-duty employee. When concerns arise within our own ranks, they must be addressed through a fair, thorough, and accountable process.

I recognize that incidents involving members of law enforcement can have a significant impact on public trust, particularly when the outcome of a criminal case raises questions within the community. The people of Eureka deserve to know that allegations involving EPD personnel are not ignored, minimized, or handled without appropriate scrutiny. They deserve confidence that we will take the necessary steps to examine concerns, address policy violations, and hold our personnel accountable.

As Chief, I take that responsibility seriously. Our commitment to accountability does not end when a criminal investigation concludes, nor does it change when the individual involved is one of our own. We have a responsibility to our employees, to the people we serve, and to the integrity of this department to ensure that concerns are addressed appropriately and that our actions reflect the standards we expect of others.

Maintaining the community’s trust requires more than words. It requires consistent action, independent oversight, and a willingness to hold ourselves to the same standards we ask our community to expect of us. That responsibility remains at the forefront of our work, and it is one we take seriously.

Godspeed,

Brian 



No comments:

Post a Comment

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.