Feb 24, 2026

Judge Graf denies defense request to disqualify Utah County prosecutors in the Tyler Robinson murder case

 

(Judge Graf: this photo is from Utah State Court website)

Utah Fourth District Judge Tony Graf was scheduled to give a ruling today on the defense request in murder suspect Tyler Robinson case to disqualify the Utah County Prosecutor's Office and eletronic media access.

Since Robinson's arrest, I have covered this case with detailed information not provided in other reporting from the Utah County Prosecutor's office as well as live court coverage of every hearing.

I already posted live on other platforms.

With the exception of defense attorney Ms. Nester who is in another trial, all other attorneys in court today for Tyler Robinson. 89% discovery provided.

Defense request to disqualify Utah County prosecutors from the Tyler Robinson case denied by Judge Graf.

Judge Graf is reading his ruling regarding disqualification. The judge is reading and reiterating many of the prosecution's arguments which, if you read the documents, were well presented. Tyler is not in court, in person today.

Judge Graf was very clear May preliminary hearing in Tyler Robinson hearing will proceed. Next court hearing on 3/13, could take up to 3 hours & then 4/17 all day hearing. These involve media access & other issues of what documents media and public can see. These other rulings are of interest mostly to media and I may not cover them live.

Attorney names for both teams are in all past coverage. Links have been provided. I covered this hearing live while also covering Humboldt courts which keep me busy, all day, daily.

At the last minute on the day his trial was supposed to start, Troy Friedman pleads guilty to an added count


On the day, forcible rape suspect Troy Friedman's trial was supposed to start, late yesterday afternoon he pleaded guilty to an added count 2 false imprisonment. Count 1, the forcible rape charge was dismissed. 

Humboldt Superior Court Judge Kaleb Cockrum took the plea. Deputy District Attorney Trent Timm is the prosecutor. Deputy Public Defender Ben McLaughlin is Friedman's attorney.

I have reached out to Ms. Timm with clarification about the minutes.

Court minutes do not list a sentencing date; list a P.O. (probation officer? ) report  "Two years probation with jail term open." Jane Doe was present via Zoom. Victim Witness Advocate read a statement.

I did have permission from her months ago to put this on the blog but waited for since a jury trial was scheduled. Friedman has now entered a plea. He is Humboldt Superior Court clerk Bonnie Jennings' ex. She told me that when she knew him, there was nothing to indicate he is capable of such behavior.


After 5 days of deliberation and readback of testimony, verdict in Richard Sanderson trial

(I will have a better booking photo Thursday)

Verdict in Richard Lyle Sanderson aka Dick aka Ricky Lyie's assault, false imprisonment and domestic violence  case. Court minutes cover sheet is up but details on verdict not up yet but they will be added to the system.

On, at 2/19 9:17 a.m. jury started deliberation, came back with a verdict on 2/23 in the afternoon. Humboldt Superior Court Judge Steward changed Sanderson's custody status to no bail.

Court trial on circumstances and aggravation is on 3/13; sentencing on 3/18/26.

Sanderson has another case in which he is charged with possession of meth which is trailing. Deputy Public Defender Ben McLaughlin is Sanderson's attorney.

Since the assigned prosecutor Deputy District Attorney Brandon Boozari is still out of the office; Deputy DA Trent Timm has been appearing on the case.

This is a previous post I did on the trial.

https://johnchiv.blogspot.com/2026/02/humboldt-juror-in-richard-sanderson.html?m=1


Feb 23, 2026

Sacramento Sheriff's blunt truth about California unleasing child molestors and predators into communities

 



Sacramento Sheriff Jim Cooper accurately calls out the failure of California to protect the public; especially from sexual predators.

"The people of Sacramento, and every parent across California, deserve answers.

The California Parole Board has granted parole to David Allen Funston, a serial child molester who used candy and toys to lure children seven years old and younger.

He was convicted of 16 counts of kidnapping and child molestation. Multiple young children were victimized, some as young as four years old. He was sentenced to more than 20 years in prison, along with three additional consecutive sentences of 25 years to life. A judge described him as “the monster parents fear the most.”

Yet today, the parole board has determined he is suitable for release. How do they explain that to those children and their parents? How do they tell families that a predator of this nature is “no longer a risk”?

Under California’s Elderly Parole Program, inmates over 50 are eligible for parole. He is 64. Age does not erase predatory behavior. It does not undo grooming. It does not restore stolen childhoods. Childhood sexual predators do not suddenly become safe because they turned 50; they cannot be rehabilitated.

Most states exclude heinous crimes like this from elderly parole. California does not.

Today, a survivor bravely spoke about what this decision means. Detective Rodriguez, who worked this case, knows firsthand what this man was capable of and how he was caught.

The Elderly Parole Program was meant for those who no longer pose a danger. In cases like this, it fails. Our number one responsibility is to protect children. That should never be controversial or partisan.

Protecting children is not rhetoric. It is common sense. Protect children first. Always."

Former Weott Community Services District employee's jury trial and resolution delayed; since assigned DA is out of the office



Jury trial was scheduled today for former employee of Weott Community Services District Julie Santibanez's embezzlement and identity theft case.

Deputy Public Defender Ryan McClurg requested a continuance which was granted by Humboldt Judge Steven Steward. There is a resolution but the assigned Deputy DA for this case, Mr. Brandon Boozari, is out of the office today due to illness. Change of plea and setting of jury trial is scheduled for 3/5/26.

DHS calls out Newsom's pardon of a convicted attempted murderer who is illegal; to be fair Gav's and Dems soft on crime laws give a pass to all CA criminals

Department of Homeland Security, those of us who live in CA see this insanity practiced everyday with no consequences for criminals or a slap on the wrist thanks to CA Dems soft on crime enabling policies. Illegal  or legal; a convicted criminal is a danger to the public. This is not a defense of Gavin Newsom. Just facts that CA needs tough law and order legislation.

Governor Gavin Newsom's Press Office shared this on X. So San Diego Diocese filed bankruptcy in response to sex abuse lawsuits is the one asked for a pardon for an illegal convicted criminal

Jury selection started late this morning in Destinee Rhamy's 2023 homicide case

 


Several trials are scheduled to start today and I was at the courthouse this morning checking on the three I have covered regularly. No other media has covered the other two cases and no other media has regularly followed homicide suspect Destinee Rhamy's case. 

Ms. Andrea Sullivan was appointed to represent Rhamy. It was good to see her back in Humboldt County this morning. Ms. Sullivan represents clients all over California and recently had a trial conclude in Riverside County.

Deputy District Attorney Roger Rees is the prosecutor for this case.

The trial had been assigned to Retired Humboldt Superior Court Judge John Feeney. Jury selection is taking place in Courtroom 5 which was closed this morning except to attorneys and Rhamy so I didn't get a chance to confirm if it is still Judge Feeney. He was in Courtroom 2 last week and  is still in that courtroom this week. E court said Judge Lawrence Killoran. This afternoon I checked and the trial judge for Rhamy is Judge Killoran.

I have linked previous coverage in this post including two previous Marsden motions Rhamy tried and were denied. I only include this because Rhamy is now all chummy with Ms. Sullivan this morning. My trial coverage will only include posts on the trial.

Mr. Rees and Ms. Sullivan went in 9:56 a.m. with Rhamy who is out of custody. Rhamy had a younger woman waiting with her before the courtroom opened who left and said, "see you later."

Also sitting outside the courtroom were Victim Witness Advocate MH with the mother of Holland Renee Elbik. Jury selection was delayed until 11, since they were waiting on three or four jurors who were on their way to the Courthouse. The jurors started coming up to the second floor and entered the courtroom at 11:08 including a local civil lawyer and a Humboldt Superior clerk supervisor. This supervisor is a experienced clerk who is still doing her work each day before jury selection and until the trial in Courtroom 5 starts each day.  

Just to address any gossip or rumors because I know the second floor well; I will disclose this since there were other people around who can vouch. I talk to attorneys and I talk to court staff all the time. At one point this morning, Ms. Sullivan was using the court computer and she was with Rhamy so I did not go in the room. When I saw Ms. Sullivan go into Courtroom 5, I went to use the computer and Rhamy said, "Andrea is logged in." I told Rhamy that Ms. Sullivan was in the courtroom and then Rhamy left. 

Elbik's mother heard me talking to people. She asked, if I was John Chiv. I said yes. She told me, " I read your blog" and said others follow my coverage and thanked me which was very kind considering this is a difficult time for her. Survivors, victims, even defendants and their families follow my coverage. "If it wasn't for you; I would not have information" is what I hear all the time. It is for these readers that I put up with the hatred, nastiness, unwarranted attacks and hours of uncompensated work.

I told Elbik's mother I was sorry to meet her under these circumstances and I would talk to her after the trial.

Nothing I said to Rhamy or the victim's mother has anything to do with the case. Potential jurors who know me say hi. I explain that other than pleasantries, why we should talk after they are excused or after the trial.

I should not have to explain myself after 12 years but this is Humboldt and anyone who has followed my coverage regularly or has been on the second floor of the Humboldt courthouse knows fiction is truer than the lies and smears spread in that toxic building and not just about me.

Feb 22, 2026

Is Curt Davis still in Eureka, Pasadena or ?

 







I was the first one to report last June that former City of Eureka deputy attorney Curt Davis was terminated. I am not going to link all the posts I have done on him including the last on January 16, 2026 where he was a no show again for a hearing, did not bother to file a response and was sanctioned $650 by Humboldt Superior Court Judge Timothy Canning.

Davis started his own law firm in Eureka working with his brother. I don't see him at the Courthouse often but that applies to several local attorneys. 

I check the State of California website often; for various reasons. Checked his profile and his Linkedin profile. He is not on the Pasadena law firm Domb & Rauchwerger website but it is on his Linkedin and California bar profile. Whether he is on contract with them or employed there; I will find out this week or eventually. Couldn't pull up his Eureka Curtis Davis Law PC website. 


Feb 21, 2026

Smartest decision made by City of Eureka was to hire Greg Holtz

 

(Photo: Greg Holtz Law

If you read me regularly, you may have noticed a familiar name in lawsuits filed by the City of Eureka. Mr. Greg Holtz, previously of Legal Services of Northern California, has his own law firm has contracted with the City of Eureka. This can be a plus for the City if the Council and City Manager use him wisely and don't eff up the one smart decision they have made recently. I got to briefly chat with him on Friday while he was waiting for Courtroom 4 to open.

Third case filed for Victor Phetsomphou; this one for indecent exposure

 



The Humboldt County DA filed charges in a 2026 case for Victor Anakin Phetsomphou. The charges were filed 2/11; an arrest warrant was issued on 2/19. Arraignment is on 3/11 when Phtemsomphou's two other cases are scheduled for preliminary hearing.

This is for Cal Poly Humboldt arrest and Phetsomphou is charged with PC 314 (1) indecent exposure.

This is how busy it has been with Humboldt courts that I have been checking regularly about  charges for Phetsomphou for the December 2025 arrest but had to wait to post this because the arraignment isn't until March.

I already reported on two other cases he had. In addition to the daily 20 plus cases, multiple continuances, repeat offenders, waiting on minutes for days because court staff is also impacted, the DA's office has to wait on arrest warrants, reports and I have 20 cases on an average to follow up daily while doing other news and national coverage.

The useless California and Humboldt elected officials know this situation is out of control. They don't care how this affects others despite being repeatedly told but neither do the people who refuse to speak up for those who inform and protect you. Especially those with money and power in Humboldt. The few who try are ignored by the same officials.

It is the elected officials' fault and they  continue to be the useless, selfish leeches collecting paychecks instead of improving the situation. Every single one of them would be fired in private industry.

Convicted molestor and Navajo Nation member sentenced to over 15 years in federal prison and 15 years of supervised release

 


30 year old Arizona resident and a Navajo Nation member Avery Billy, was sentenced this week to 188 months in prison after which he will be on 180 months of supervised release for the sexual abuse of two young girls who lived on Navajo nation. The victims were in first grade when Billy started abusing them.

Max Aylward arrested by EPD for indecent exposure, resisting arrest and being drunk in public

 


Max Trenton Aylward was arrested by Eureka Police Department yesterday for PC 314 (1) indecent exposure, PC 148(a)(1) resisting arrest and PC 647 (f) drunk in public.

These are all misdemeanors. Unless this happened near a school or there is any other reason, this is just one of hundreds of cases that will go nowhere. Based on 12 years of covering Humboldt courts, there are going to be no consequences.

Feb 20, 2026

33 year old San Francisco man sentenced to 20 years in federal prison for production, distribution and receipt of child sexual abuse material

 


33 year old Henry Muller has been in custody since his arrest in 2023. The U.S. Attorney's Office of Northern District California issued a press release this evening about Muller being sentenced on February 12, 2026 to 20 Years in federal prison for production, distribution and receipt of child sexual abuse material. In addition to the prison term, Judge Edward Chen sentenced Muller to a 15-year period of supervised release which will start after his term of imprisonment.

Muller's prosecution was a result of an investigation by the FBI and San Mateo County Sheriff’s Office.

APD arrests Kason Severe for probation violation, firearm and drug charges

Arcata Police Department arrested repeat offender Kason Severe yesterday. APD received a tip Severe was attempting to sell an illegal firearm on Snapchat and was in possession of controlled substances.

Weitchpec's Molli Myers appointed by Newsom to NCWQCB

 

(Photo :Ridges to Riffles Indigenous Conservation Group)

"Molli Myers, of Weitchpec, has been appointed to the North Coast Water Quality Control Board.  Myers has been the Chief Operating Officer for the Ridges to Riffles Indigenous Conservation Group since 2022. This position requires Senate confirmation and the compensation is $250 per diem. Myers is a Democrat." --Just released by Governor Gavin Newsom's Office of Appointments.

Once again, Humboldt Superior Court Dept 6 appointment MIA

Yesterday, another judicial appointments press release from California Governor Gavin Newsom's Office. Once again, Humboldt Department 6 temporary appointment MIA.

They shouldn't have said it won't be on the ballot this June before making an appointment. Candidates have a March 6 deadline & for months, Humboldt courts are having to pay Retired or Visiting judges.

Local attorney Elan Firpo sued for breach of contract by Cassie Brown

 

(Photo from Stokes, Hamer, Kirk, Firpo & Auwarter, LLP website, Firpo is second from left)

I have covered Ms. Elan Firpo for years. First as a former Humboldt Deputy District Attorney. Regular, longtime readers will remember her from my coverage of the Bodhi tree case. She also ran for DA in 2014. I covered her campaign. She had her own law firm, Firpo Law Firm right by the Courthouse but most recently is an attorney at Stokes, Hamer, Kirk, Firpo & Auwarter, LLP.

Today, there was a case management conference scheduled in a breach of contract lawsuit filed on 8/20/25 by Cassie Brown vs Elan Firpo. Civil minutes could be up very late today or days later. 

There is a demurrer scheduled on 3/9/26 and there is an update that the CMC is set to coincide with demurrer. There is also a 4/24/26 hearing on Order to show cause for failure to appear.

Brown is represented by Oakland attorney Michael R. Huff Oakland who has filed an opposition to the demurrer.

Ms. Firpo has hired William A. Munoz and Bill Munoz of Freeman, Mathis, Gary LLP which is Roseville law firm.

I have included the complaint and other court documents if you want details.

Another California civil attorney contacted me after the post saying, "This is a malpractice case.  Professional negligence = malpractice."

Got to give a shout out to Humboldt County Sherrif's Office

 

(Humboldt County Sheriff William Honsal)

(Humboldt County Undersheriff JD Braud)

Got to give a shout out to Humboldt County Sheriff's Office for their timely press releases, some the same day of arrests & their professionalism in prompt responses & treating all media fairly. This is a small, rural County, also short staffed & they deserve kudos for all they do.