"No physical evidence, no SART exam but they go 10 layers deep into his porn"

"I can play my dad, my mom and pretty much anyone else." This statement made by Jane Doe #1 was how Ms. Andrea Sullivan started her opening statement in the Chad Smith case.

"The evidence in this case is disturbing but not for the reasons you think. "

"Mr. Smith is a flawed person. He made mistakes as a husband and a father but sexually abusing children is not one of those
mistakes."

Ms. Sullivan talked about Jane Doe #1's curiosity about sex developing as a 13 year old. Jane Doe # 1 had "unfettered and unchecked access to electronic devices. She developed an active fantasy life."

"There is a very disturbing exchange on Skype between Jane Doe #1 and 'Michael Stephenson" ." Ms. Sullivan said quotes around the name because we don't know if that is his real name.
Stephenson is a 30 year old man in England with whom Jane Doe#1 had sexually explicit correspondence. The remark about her playing her dad, her mom and anyone else is part of that exchange.

"You will see a different side of Jane Doe #1.

Amy Smith finds a journal entry in Jane Doe #1's bedroom. Ms. Sullivan said that the journal entry "shows her ability to craft a story about how she views her life."

This prompted the police investigation. The first time EPD found no evidence of wrongdoing.

Due to the restraining order, Chad Smith cannot see his biological son. "Mr. Smith made an unfortunate choice to correspond with Jane Doe #1 about his biological son Benjamin." Ms. Sullivan said that Jane Doe #1 was "a window into his son's life."

Ms. Sullivan said that Chad Smith goads Jane Doe #1 to create havoc in Amy Smith's life so he can get back into Amy Smith's life.

In February 2017, Jane Doe #1 begins sending romantic emails to Chad Smith. The communication was one way, said Ms. Sullivan.

"Mr. Smith tries to set boundaries. When she becomes overtly sexual with Mr. Smith, he tries again to set boundaries."

"Mr. Smith did send some sexually inappropriate joking emails. No one should be convicted of the counts in this case based on a dirty joke."

Chad Smith ceased communication with Jane Doe #1 and that is when Jane Doe #1 claimed she had been molested by him.

Jane Doe #1 and Jane Doe #2 have known each other since kindergarten. "Jane Doe #2 did not independently remember the sexual abuse. The allegations are a coordination between two families which led to the disclosure. This "seriously diminishes Jane Doe #2's credibility.,"

"Jane Doe #1 has never been examined. She has never been on birth control. She was never checked for STDs or penile penetration."

"A SART nurse will come in and testify for the defense.,"

"The bulk of the evidence is Jane Doe #1. Her story, her persona and her allegations change depending on who the audience is," said Ms. Sullivan. There is "anger,manipulation and filthy language when no one is watching."

"To find Mr. Smith guilty hinges on Jane Doe #1's credibility."

"There is no physical evidence, no SART exam but they go 10 layers deep in his porn."

"An adult man watching legal porn doesn't mean he is a child molestor."

Previous post:
https://johnchiv.blogspot.com/2019/04/deputy-das-use-of-jane-doe-1-and-2.html?m=1